Whats the life span of nimh battery??

Feel free to discuss anything NON-R/C related that is on your mind.

Moderators: scr8p, klavy69

User avatar
longboardnj
Approved Member
Posts: 1337
Joined: Sun Jun 29, 2008 11:52 am
Location: new jersey
Been thanked: 2 times

Whats the life span of nimh battery??

Post by longboardnj »

Whats the life span of nimh battery?? how many years are they worth keeping?? i have some old race packs that im debating on junking.. if i cycle them they seem to work ok..sometimes i even charge my new nimh for about 45 and then they only last 3 min in a traxxas vxl.. then i charge them again i get good runtime... is there any way i can test my bats to find out if they are good??

Charlie don't surf
Approved Member
Posts: 8921
Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 2:44 pm
Location: USA
Been thanked: 8 times

Re: Whats the life span of nimh battery??

Post by Charlie don't surf »

You can cycle them a few times to try to get then back- depending on what NiMh packs they are (3300/4200/4600sho/worlds) some will come back better than others but these packs had a prime output and storage for weeks in the later packs.

Go get some cheap (30 bucks) Turnigy lipos and don't bother wasting time trying to bring them to a 1/4 of what they once were-

User avatar
longboardnj
Approved Member
Posts: 1337
Joined: Sun Jun 29, 2008 11:52 am
Location: new jersey
Been thanked: 2 times

Re: Whats the life span of nimh battery??

Post by longboardnj »

i feel the lipo stuff is too dangerous.. i store all my rc stuff in my studio apartment...the 3300 race packs i have are over 6 years old..i know age plays a factor with bats . i really just want to be reassured its a wase of time trying to get life out of them before i junk them.. the fastest thing i run is a vxl rustler ,i was thinking of just getting 2 or 3, 3000 duratrax packs for $20 each and calling it a day... the other hand i dont want to junk the packs if they are still good...

AYKBOBCAT
Approved Member
Posts: 585
Joined: Wed Nov 22, 2006 2:32 pm
Location: Bas St-Laurent, Canada

Re: Whats the life span of nimh battery??

Post by AYKBOBCAT »

longboardnj wrote:i feel the lipo stuff is too dangerous.. i store all my rc stuff in my studio apartment...the 3300 race packs i have are over 6 years old..i know age plays a factor with bats . i really just want to be reassured its a wase of time trying to get life out of them before i junk them.. the fastest thing i run is a vxl rustler ,i was thinking of just getting 2 or 3, 3000 duratrax packs for $20 each and calling it a day... the other hand i dont want to junk the packs if they are still good...

I'm with you on this... I also have 3 old nimh and I didn't touch them for more than a year now. I think I'll try to cycle them a few times.... I also don't like the safty issue with Lipos...

User avatar
SRTracer121
Approved Member
Posts: 512
Joined: Sun Jul 04, 2010 12:15 am

Re: Whats the life span of nimh battery??

Post by SRTracer121 »

lipos are not dangerous. if you abuse them by over-discharging them, overcharging them at a different setting (as nimhs for example) and then yeah it can bite you on the keaster but overall they are fine. ive had packs that were trashed and i went to blow them up for funnsies and i couldnt. you really have to abuse the packs to get the to fail catastrophically. most of the time if you run them too hard (run a low "c" pack in an 8th scale for example) then they puff and you can them (though a little puffing is fine) ive got 10 packs sitting right next to me in my bedroom of my dads house and i dont give them a second thought.

anyway if you are stuck on the idea that you rather run nimhs id just buy new packs. the promatch enerG 4600 matched packs are probably the best bang for your buck. probbly the best on the market overall too. i had a few matched/zapped enerG's from spc when he still sold them and they were the bees knees. better then EP cells atleast and miles ahead of the old GP 3300's

http://www.promatchracing.com/products.php?cat=6

Jay Dub
Approved Member
Posts: 1136
Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2008 1:04 am
Location: San Jose, Ca.
Been thanked: 1 time

Re: Whats the life span of nimh battery??

Post by Jay Dub »

The safety issue with Lipos, is really overarated. I have never seen (in person) any real problem. Recycle the old packs (they really are no good), and invest in some cheaper LiPo's like charlie said. You will be happy you did. -Jeff

User avatar
SRTracer121
Approved Member
Posts: 512
Joined: Sun Jul 04, 2010 12:15 am

Re: Whats the life span of nimh battery??

Post by SRTracer121 »

ive seen a fair number of lipo fires but they were user induced, the one set failed because a screw came up through the bottom of the guys battery box (1/8th buggy) and he kept wrecking packs till he caught on. the other (from the same guy) did the same thing i had done a month earlier, he charged the packs as nimhs and they puffed then caught fire (lipos dont explode fyi, its an intense chemical fire) i was lucky and it happened to (in my case, 2 packs at the same time :oops: )me outside, his were in his garage. ruined his beloved hitec aggressor and his one charger that the pack was sitting on. luckily his work area has tile backsplash so nothing else went. :shock:



now, for the sake of conversation, the way you put out a lipo fire is with sand. you smother it and deny it oxygen to burn. thats why ROAR requires a bucket of sand be within so many feet of the pit area.

User avatar
longboardnj
Approved Member
Posts: 1337
Joined: Sun Jun 29, 2008 11:52 am
Location: new jersey
Been thanked: 2 times

Re: Whats the life span of nimh battery??

Post by longboardnj »

thanks for the info guys but i just want to stick with nimh for now.. i love the new 2.4 radios and brushless systems but this oldschool guy wants to stay away from lipo for now.. besides i had fun with brushed motors and 1700nicads.. im sure runing brushless motors and 3000nimh stick pack will be fun...

now back to my problem... i have 8 nimh packs and 5 nicads (i had 9 nicads but got rid of 4)... the reason i am asking for advice is cause ive had 7 year old race packs take a better charge then my new traxxas 7 cell 3000nimh .. i know that pack is good and i just need to charge and use it a few times and it will be fine.. i have five 7 year old race packs that i know dont have 400-600 charge cycles (thats "nimhs life span").. the problem is the packs are 7 years old and i know if a bat in an atv/motorcycle was 7 years old i would junk it.. if i could hook up my old packs to a machine and i found out the bat only had 50% life left id just junk them.. the point of all this is i dont want to spend $60 on 3 duratrax 3000 nimh stick packs just to find out i get the same kind of performance out of the old packs i have now

Charlie don't surf
Approved Member
Posts: 8921
Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 2:44 pm
Location: USA
Been thanked: 8 times

Re: Whats the life span of nimh battery??

Post by Charlie don't surf »

As they went higher in the mah ratings and discharge rates the NiMh cells became less stable. The older ones were more consistent than the later ones. I would bet money that after 50 cycles anything over a 3000 pack lost 30% of its output and capcity. The need traxxas packs are still newer unstable chemistry. NiCads however seem to be good for almost ever.

User avatar
SRTracer121
Approved Member
Posts: 512
Joined: Sun Jul 04, 2010 12:15 am

Re: Whats the life span of nimh battery??

Post by SRTracer121 »

do you need a discharge rack or bulbs? i might have some id get rid of for a little nitro fuel money (10-15 bucks i guess) ive got a trinity "real time" rack and a bulb discharger set.

User avatar
longboardnj
Approved Member
Posts: 1337
Joined: Sun Jun 29, 2008 11:52 am
Location: new jersey
Been thanked: 2 times

Re: Whats the life span of nimh battery??

Post by longboardnj »

Charlie don't surf wrote:As they went higher in the mah ratings and discharge rates the NiMh cells became less stable. The older ones were more consistent than the later ones. I would bet money that after 50 cycles anything over a 3000 pack lost 30% of its output and capcity. The need traxxas packs are still newer unstable chemistry. NiCads however seem to be good for almost ever.
yea it stinks how some new products are worse then older products..

User avatar
longboardnj
Approved Member
Posts: 1337
Joined: Sun Jun 29, 2008 11:52 am
Location: new jersey
Been thanked: 2 times

Re: Whats the life span of nimh battery??

Post by longboardnj »

SRTracer121 wrote:do you need a discharge rack or bulbs? i might have some id get rid of for a little nitro fuel money (10-15 bucks i guess) ive got a trinity "real time" rack and a bulb discharger set.
i think i have something but thanks if i need it ill let you know.. i was thinking of making something like a electric heater to discharge.. my place gets kinda cold this time of year..

Jay Dub
Approved Member
Posts: 1136
Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2008 1:04 am
Location: San Jose, Ca.
Been thanked: 1 time

Re: Whats the life span of nimh battery??

Post by Jay Dub »

Well, if you have your heart set on NiMh batteries, then what you really need to do is rather complicated. First, figure out what type of cell you have, and then find out what care regimine is prescribed (most manufacturers had this available at one time). It really does vary for every type of cell. There are some general guidelines, but to get the best from your packs you need to do some research.

Basics: Never discharge your cells past .9 volts per cell (very difficult to do with pre assembled packs) -it will ruin the cells (you spoke of inconsistency in run time and perfiormance :wink: ). After every run (remember you can't run your packs all the way down), tray your packs with a discharge tray (Rayspeed made an excellent one).

Then you need to charge them before storage (if you don't they will be damaged). They need to be stored with a 1000 Mah per week of storage. 3 weeks = 3000 Mah of charge. If they are 3800 Mah packs, then they can't sit for 4 weeks without damaging the packs (providing they were in perfect shape to begin with). Then they need to be discharged before they are charged for a run.

To charge them' you need to find a charger than has the peak detection fcn adjustable, and it need to be adjusted for each type of cell, and pack configuration (eg. 4 cell, 6 cell, 7cell etc.) -Ip cells, Ib cells, Powers, GP etc.

Next you really can't run them more than once a week, or you will damage the cells. Some cells can go 4 days, but you should find out which ones (research). And, if you do everything correctly, you should get 20 or so runs in tip top form. If you missed anything, then you can count on reduced performance -Yaaaayyy! Now you know the basics of caring for NiMh cells! :roll: -Jeff

User avatar
SRTracer121
Approved Member
Posts: 512
Joined: Sun Jul 04, 2010 12:15 am

Re: Whats the life span of nimh battery??

Post by SRTracer121 »

im not sure i believe the whole part about running packs more then once a week. ive been told by 2 different mfg's that as long as they are allowed to cool to ambient temperature between a charge or discharge you can charge and run them as much as you want.

Jay Dub
Approved Member
Posts: 1136
Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2008 1:04 am
Location: San Jose, Ca.
Been thanked: 1 time

Re: Whats the life span of nimh battery??

Post by Jay Dub »

Of course they will tell you that, they sell more batteries. Plus once a week sounds shitty to tell customers. So their batteries sound better if they tell you that you can run them as much as you want. But, I can tell you as a national champion, 100% sponsored factory racer for nearly 20 years, including up and through the NiMh craze that what I wrote is what they tell the factory drivers about the batteries -NOT the general public. Believe what you want, I have noting to gain by giving out this information. This is simply what my sponsors told me during the NiMh heyday. The guy asked how to best take care of his NiMh batteries. I am giving him the best info available.

Post Reply

Create an account or sign in to join the discussion

You need to be a member in order to post a reply

Create an account

Not a member? register to join our community
Members can start their own topics & subscribe to topics
It’s free and only takes a minute

Register

Sign in

  • Similar Topics
    Replies
    Views
    Last post
  • Best nimh battery?
    by Dave145 » » in Vintage Electronics
    8 Replies
    1041 Views
    Last post by fredswain
  • NIMH battery conditioning
    by Frankentruck » » in Vintage Electronics
    6 Replies
    751 Views
    Last post by Frankentruck
  • NiMh Battery Cells
    by Winger » » in Vintage Electronics
    1 Replies
    796 Views
    Last post by TRX-1-3
  • Battery trays for NiMH/LiPo
    by Flargen » » in RC10 Buggy Forum
    3 Replies
    832 Views
    Last post by Flargen
  • NiMh battery charging???? Which Batteries are Better??
    by tecnica2001 » » in Off-Topic / Chit-Chat
    24 Replies
    1811 Views
    Last post by tecnica2001
  • Recommended NIMH Battery for 1984 Edinger
    by jchappell » » in RC10 Buggy Forum
    1 Replies
    546 Views
    Last post by THEYTOOKMYTHUMB
  • DIY 6 cell battery packs: loose NiMh sourcing?
    by TRX-1-3 » » in Vintage Electronics
    7 Replies
    1657 Views
    Last post by isobarik
  • NIMH battery problem - half of cells warm, low power
    by paul » » in Vintage Electronics
    4 Replies
    727 Views
    Last post by paul

Return to “Off-Topic / Chit-Chat”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 39 guests